The Town of Clay Zoning Board of Appeals unanimously approved area variances at its April 13 meeting for a new Community Bank branch and drive-thru on State Route 31 and for a detached garage on Oswego Road, in a session that opened at 5:59 p.m. and adjourned at 6:16 p.m.
●SEQR: the board classified all of the night's actions as Type II with a negative declaration; motion by Chairperson Vivian Mason, seconded by David Porter, unanimously carried.
●Case #1999 (Robert Aluzzo/John Anthony Properties LLC, 8285 Oswego Road): approved variances cutting the side yard setback from 20 to 9 feet and raising the accessory-structure height limit from 12 to 18 feet for a 16-by-24-foot detached garage; motion by Michael Becker, seconded by Porter; roll call unanimous (DesRosier, Porter, Becker, Mason all in favor).
●Case #2000 (Erik Turner/Community Bank, 4000 State Route 31): approved variances reducing the required side yard setback from 75 to 44 feet and the site perimeter landscape strip from 30 to 25 feet for a new bank building and drive-thru; motion by Becker, seconded by Porter; roll call unanimous (DesRosier, Porter, Becker, Mason all in favor).
●Both approvals are conditioned on construction matching the site plan submitted as Exhibit A.
●Planning & Development Commissioner Brian Bender said the Onondaga County Board had submitted referral comments on the bank project, but that they pertain to the project's still-pending Special Permit and Site Plan reviews rather than the variance request.
●Representatives for both applicants acknowledged, under the board's standard five-part test, that the need for their variances was self-created.
●No members of the public spoke for or against either application, and the Planning Department reported no remonstrance to either request.
●Deputy Chairperson Karen Liebi and member Ryan Frantzis were absent; alternate member Michael Becker sat in, casting votes and making both approval motions.
The Town of Clay Zoning Board of Appeals granted area variances April 13 that will let Community Bank build a new branch with a drive-thru on State Route 31, fit onto the eastern end of an existing commercial plaza's parking lot.
The board voted to reduce the required side yard setback from 75 feet to 44 feet and to shrink the mandated site perimeter landscape strip from 30 feet to 25 feet for the project at 4000 State Route 31, Tax Map #055.-01-03.1. Lisa Wennberg, a project manager with Keplinger Freeman Associates representing applicant Erik Turner of Community Bank, told the board the reduced setback and buffer were needed to fit the new building and drive-thru into the plaza's existing layout while keeping the site's traffic flow intact. She pointed to the alignment of Soule Road as providing enough separation to offset the smaller buffer, and noted that neighboring commercial buildings already carry similar setbacks.
Answering the board's standard five-part test for area variances, Wennberg acknowledged the need for both reductions was self-created — a product of the plaza's existing footprint rather than any hardship imposed on the applicant — but said the project would remain compatible with the area's commercial character. Planning & Development Commissioner Brian Bender told the board his department had received no objections to the application, though the Onondaga County Board had submitted referral comments; he said those comments apply to the bank's still-pending Special Permit and Site Plan reviews rather than to the variance request before the board that night. No members of the public spoke for or against the project, and the board voted unanimously — Mary Lou DesRosier, David Porter, Michael Becker and Chairperson Vivian Mason all in favor — to approve the variances on condition the project match the site plan submitted as Exhibit A.
The board handled one other case the same night: a variance for a detached garage at 8285 Oswego Road sought by Robert Aluzzo of John Anthony Properties LLC. Aluzzo's engineer, Steve Calocerinos of Calocerinos Engineering, told the board his client bought the rental property and is renovating it, and wants to add a 16-by-24-foot detached garage because the house's side-door layout ruled out attaching a garage to the home. The variance reduces the required side yard setback from 20 feet to 9 feet and raises the height limit for an accessory structure from 12 feet to 18 feet. Calocerinos likewise told the board the need was self-created but said the design followed standard building practice and would add value to the property. That vote was also unanimous, with the same condition tying construction to the Exhibit A site plan.
Both applications moved through the board without any recorded opposition — the Planning Department reported no remonstrance to either request, and no one from the audience spoke on either case. The board had opened the meeting by voting to classify all of the night's actions as Type II under the State Environmental Quality Review Act, meaning each received a negative declaration without further environmental review. Chairperson Mason gaveled in at 5:59 p.m. and adjourned by 6:16 p.m., with Deputy Chairperson Karen Liebi and member Ryan Frantzis absent and alternate Michael Becker filling in to cast votes and make both approval motions.
The bank variances clear one hurdle for the Route 31 project, but Bender's comment about the pending county referral is a reminder that Community Bank's application still faces Special Permit and Site Plan review before construction can begin.
Minutes report. Drafted by our AI minutes pipeline from the official minutes — the board's own record of the meeting — and checked against that record by an automated verification gate before publication.
●Unanimously approved Case #1998, granting area variances for property at 8111 Maple Road.
●Reduced front yard setback requirement from 75 feet to 72 feet.
●Reduced side yard setback requirement from 25 feet to 17 feet.
●Authorized construction of a new 12-by-24-foot addition for a home office.
●Approved a negative declaration under the State Environmental Quality Review (SEQR).
The board met and heard new variance cases, including Allied Sign's request for oversized signage on Route 31. The file the town posted as these minutes is actually a March agenda; we have asked the town to post the correct file.
●VFW Pavillion Project (Case #1995):** Approved area variances to reduce front yard setback (from 100 ft to 78 ft) and parking spaces (from 54 to 35) for a new outdoor pavilion at 5366 Caughdenoy Road. Vote: 5-0.
●Residential Shed Replacement (Case #1996):** Approved an area variance to reduce side yard setback (from 7.5 ft to 2.5 ft) for a new 10x16 shed at 5225 Cremona Trail. Vote: 5-0.
●Board Organization:** Unanimously adopted the 2025 scheduling calendar and designated the second Monday of each month as the regular meeting date.
●SEQR Determination:** Board determined all new actions were Type II under the State Environmental Quality Review Act, issuing a negative declaration.
Fire Access Concerns Push Oswego Road Pole Barn Case to August, After Bid to Cut Setback From 25 Feet to 2.3 Feet
●Case #2001: Applicant Greg Fischel of Allied Sign Company (3567 State Route 31) withdrew a request for a larger freestanding sign but won approval, 4-1 (Liebi opposed), for a third, non-illuminated wall sign matching the size of an existing oval sign.
●Case #2005: Paul Licari (8894 Caughdenoy Road) withdrew his application for two setback variances tied to a proposed warehouse and parking area.
●Case #2006: Sarah Vartabedian (9656 Beaver Watch Path) unanimously won a front yard setback reduction from 25 feet to 10 feet and a 6-foot fence height allowance, to gain backyard space and family privacy.
●Case #2007: Ulrich Sign Co. Inc. (3687 State Route 31), represented by Chris McCaffrey, won approval 4-1 (Liebi opposed) to enlarge a freestanding sign from 32 to 40.11 square feet; Planning & Development Commissioner Brian Bender confirmed the applicant is acquiring the adjacent property to the west and is scheduled before the Planning Board on July 22.
●Case #2008: Finger Lakes Construction (8247 Oswego Road), represented by Anthony Natale, sought a front yard setback reduction from 25 feet to 2.3 feet and a height increase from 12 to 18.4 feet for a pole barn. Code Enforcement Commissioner Joseph Grispino and Code Enforcement Officer Mike Brown said the barn as proposed would hinder fire department access; Grispino said Code Enforcement and the fire department had agreed a 10-foot setback would be "palatable." No vote was taken on the variances; the board voted unanimously to adjourn the hearing to August 10, and the applicant is expected to reconsider the barn's size.
●Case #2009: Johann Weigl (200 Fletcher Drive) unanimously won a front yard setback reduction from 16.6 feet to 0 feet and a 6-foot fence height allowance to connect an existing chain-link fence, to be replaced with vinyl, to the house.
●The board accepted the June 8, 2026 meeting minutes and voted to classify all new actions at the July 13 meeting as Type II under SEQR, resulting in a negative declaration.
●The minutes contain two internal inconsistencies not resolved in the article: Case #2001's applicant is named "Greg Fischel" in the case caption but "Mr. Fishel" in the body text; and roll calls for Cases #2006-#2009 list a "Ms. DesRosiers" who does not appear on the meeting's Present or Absent rosters, in the seat Case #2001's roll call assigns to Michael Becker.
Community Discussion
0 commentsBe the first to comment on this story.