Clay, New York
· Wednesday, September 2, 2026· Sep 2, 2026
click for forecast ↓↓
📐 Planning Board
Redevelopment Planned for Beloved "Sweetheart Corner" in Clay
The Planning Board has unanimously recommended a zoning change for the "Sweetheart Corner" intersection at Wally and West Taft Roads, paving the way for new commercial development and a bank drive-thru while preserving existing landmarks.
●Recommended approval of a zone change from residential to regional commercial (RC-1) for 102 ½ Wally Road (Sweetheart Corner) in a 7-0 vote.
●Issued a Negative Declaration under SEQR for the Ironhorn Enterprises warehouse project on Henry Clay Blvd, determining no significant environmental impact.
●Adjourned the Northern Credit Union site plan review to May 13, 2026, due to ongoing wetland issues.
●Adjourned the EV Charging Stations site plan review on Buckley Road to April 22, 2026.
●Adjourned the Donald Gabor subdivision preliminary plat on Morgan Road to April 22, 2026.
●Adjourned the Mauro Subdivision preliminary plat on Elmcrest Road to April 22, 2026 to resolve fence and drainage easement issues.
A familiar intersection in Clay is slated for a facelift following a unanimous vote by the town Planning Board this week.
During their regular meeting on April 8, the board voted 7-0 to recommend a zone change for the property known as "Sweetheart Corner," located at 102 ½ Wally Road. The recommendation now moves to the Town Board for final approval.
Matt Napierala of Napierala Consulting, representing the applicant 5380 Sweetheart Corner LLC, told the board that the zone change from one-family residential to regional commercial (RC-1) is the first step in a larger redevelopment plan for the busy corner.
The proposal aims to reinvigorate the site while maintaining its character. Napierala confirmed that the existing Rite Aid structure will remain, albeit converted into office or commercial space, and the current coffee shop—a local landmark—will stay in operation.
Napierala stated that they are looking for a zone change to allow for future redevelopment, according to the meeting minutes.
The primary new feature under the RC-1 zoning would be an outparcel drive-thru bank on the west frontage of West Taft Road. The change would also facilitate additional parking and improved access to Wally Road.
Board members discussed the procedural steps ahead, which include lot consolidation and applications for area variances regarding setback regulations with the Zoning Board of Appeals. A Special Permit will also be required for the bank drive-thru services.
Board member Jim Palumbo inquired about the "Sweetheart Market" sign during the discussion. Napierala confirmed that the sign would remain, preserving a piece of the town's aesthetic history.
The board's recommendation was based on Standard Form #50, stating that the change "has no significant detrimental effects." The Town Board will now handle the State Environmental Quality Review (SEQR) process.
**Warehouse Project Clears Environmental Hurdle**
In other business, the board moved a significant warehouse project forward. Ironhorn Enterprises, represented by Alex Samoray of Keplinger Freeman Associates, is seeking to amend the site plan for a warehouse facility at 7245 Henry Clay Blvd.
The board focused heavily on environmental factors, specifically wetlands. After reviewing the Environmental Assessment Form (EAF), Deputy Chair Russ Mitchell noted that while construction may occur near shallow water tables and wetlands, the impacts would be mitigated through strict compliance with permits from the Army Corps of Engineers and the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC).
"Negative impacts to US Army Corps of Engineers and/or NYSDEC jurisdictional wetlands... will be avoided through compliance with required wetlands permits," Mitchell said during the recap.
The board issued a Negative Declaration, determining the project will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. The case was adjourned to June 10, 2026, to allow time for DEC permitting.
**Other Business**
Several projects were adjourned to future dates to allow applicants time to refine plans:
* **Northern Credit Union (5004-5008 West Taft Road):** Adjourned to May 13, 2026. The applicant is continuing to work through wetland issues.
* **Chad Mutter EV Charging Stations (7293 Buckley Road):** Adjourned to April 22, 2026.
* **Donald Gabor Subdivision (8150 Morgan Road):** Adjourned to April 22, 2026.
* **Scott Merle Builders (Mauro Subdivision, 4095 & 4101 Elmcrest Road):** Adjourned to April 22, 2026. Board members discussed a fence encroaching on a drainage easement, which needs to be resolved before the preliminary plat can be approved.
The next Planning Board meeting is scheduled for April 22, 2026, at Town Hall.
Early coverage (re-verified). An early article, drafted by AI before our verification gate existed. Every one was later adversarially re-reviewed against its source record, and the errors found were corrected and republished in August 2026.
●Board approved the minutes of the April 8, 2026 meeting, 6-0.
●Case #2026-022 Hinerwadels Subdivision (J. Alberici & Sons, 5300 West Taft Road): preliminary-plat hearing on a 91-lot subdivision (single-family homes plus two office parcels, one planned as a day care) on 29 acres; DOT's initial traffic review pointed toward a signal at West Taft Road/Rockland Drive at the developer's expense; adjourned to June 10, 6-0.
●Case #2026-026 Buckley Two-Family Conversion (Steven Calocerinis, 4793 Buckley Road): not referred to the Planning Board by the Town Board; no action taken.
●Cases #2025-003/004 Wetzel Service Yard (John E. Fisher Construction Co., 4593 Wetzel Road): still in litigation over wetland issues; adjourned to June 10, 6-0.
●Case #2025-044 Chad Mutter EV Charging Stations (7293 Buckley Road): board identified an ADA-accessibility gap between the charging-station parking and the building entrance; adjourned to May 13, 6-0.
●Case #2026-009 Gabor Subdivision Phase II (8150 Morgan Road): no one present to represent the applicant; adjourned to May 13, 6-0.
●Case #2026-013 Mauro Subdivision (Scott Merle Builders, 4095 & 4101 Elmcrest Road): board adopted a negative SEQR declaration and granted final plat approval splitting two lots into four, in a series of 6-0 votes, conditioned on a license agreement already filed with the county covering a driveway encroachment between the properties.
●Case #2026-015 VFW Post 951 (5366 Caughdenoy Road): withdrawn due to wetland issues.
●Cases #2026-017/018 The Learning Experience (Park Ridge Path): board requested cleaner drawings, a marked HVAC location, and more legible planting and elevation plans; adjourned to May 13, 6-0.
●Case #2026-019 Goguen Service Yard (7835 Goguen Drive): board found the stormwater pond's topographic survey lacked a licensed surveyor's seal and required a new survey to confirm 2022 compliance before further approval; adjourned to June 10, 6-0.
●Meeting adjourned at 8:45 p.m., 6-0; next meeting May 13, 2026.
Zoning Questions Stall Elmcrest Subdivision as Clay Delays VFW Pavilion, 144-Child Day Care Plans
●Board approved the April 22, 2026 minutes, 6-0 (Mr. Henty abstained)
●Case #2026-028, West Taft Summit Credit Union (4955 West Taft Road) site plan adjourned to May 27, 2026 pending resolution of a county WEP easement issue and other plan corrections, 7-0
●Case #2025-037, W Taft Northern Credit Union (5004-5008 West Taft Road) site plan adjourned to June 10, 2026 for a generator enclosure detail and a driveway/property-line item, 7-0
●Case #2025-44, Chad Mutter/EV Charging Stations (7293 Buckley Road) amended site plan granted a SEQR negative declaration and site plan approval, both 7-0, conditioned on the engineer adding a required state expiration date to the PE stamp
●Case #2025-054, Black Creek Equestrian Center (9605 Black Creek Road) adjourned to July 8, 2026 at the applicant's request, 7-0
●Cases #2026-009/#2026-046, Gabor Subdivision Phase II and Final Plan (8150 Morgan Road) adjourned to May 27, 2026, 7-0, after Mr. Palumbo raised concern that shifting a lot line would leave a solar farm setback at roughly 25 feet instead of the previously approved 50 feet, and Ms. Guinup objected that a long-standing house on the new Lot 2A does not meet setbacks and said she would vote against the plan as discussed
●Cases #2026-017/#2026-018, The Learning Experience (8233 Park Ridge Path) special permit and amended site plan granted SEQR negative declarations and approvals, all 7-0, with the site plan approval noting signage is not included
●Sign permit for Allied Sign Company/Tully's Tenders (3567 State Route 31) for two wall signs approved, 7-0
●Sign permit for Kassis Superior Signs/ASA American Steel and Aluminum (4522 Wetzel Road) for one wall sign and one freestanding sign approved, 7-0
Clay Planning Board Approves Byrne Dairy Digital Signage, Flags Concerns Over Battery Storage
●Approved special permit for Byrne Dairy electronic sign (Case #2026-010) by a 7-0 vote.
●Voted 5-0 to send negative recommendations to the Town Board regarding Nexamp battery storage proposals (Cases #2026-001 and #2026-002), citing lack of zoning laws and proximity to residents.
●Adjourned review of Ironhorn Enterprises site plan to April 8, 2026, to establish lead agency status under SEQR.
●Continued review of Northside Baptist Church site plan to March 18, 2026, to fix lighting technicalities.
●Adjourned John E. Fisher Construction cases to April 22, 2026, due to outstanding wetland issues.
●Adjourned Northern Credit Union site plan review to March 18, 2026.
Clay Planning Board Delays Vote on 61-Lot Lawton Road Subdivision, Debates Traffic at Proposed R&F Plaza Bank
●Board approved the minutes of the May 13, 2026 meeting (7-0).
●Community Bank N.A.'s proposed 2,717-sf branch with drive-thru and ATM lanes at the Raymour & Flanigan Plaza (4000 Route 31) was adjourned to July 8, 2026, for a revised plan addressing lighting, HVAC screening, and traffic-flow concerns (7-0).
●West Herr Automotive Group's zone change referral (Route 31, .78 acres, NC-1 to HC-1) to expand dealership parking was recommended to the Town Board (7-0).
●Cornerstone Homes CNY LLC's zone change referral for a 61-lot subdivision on Lawton Road (RA-100 to R-7.5) was adjourned to June 10, 2026, pending comment from the Town of Cicero; no vote was taken on the rezoning itself (7-0 to adjourn).
●Gabor Subdivision Phase II (8150 Morgan Road): board adopted a SEQR negative declaration (7-0) and approved the final plat (6-0, one member opposed).
●Summit Federal Credit Union's site plan for 4955 West Taft Road was adjourned to June 10, 2026, at the applicant's request (7-0).
●Farmstead Subdivision (Maple Roads Associates) final plat was adjourned to July 8, 2026, at the applicant's request (7-0).
Credit Union Expansion Wins Approval; Board Members Recuse Themselves from Battery Projects
●Unanimously recommended zone change and special permits for The Summit FCU to construct a 3,100 sq. ft. branch with a drive-thru at 4955 West Taft Rd (Vote 7-0).
●Heard a presentation from Nexamp regarding a 5,000 kWh battery energy storage system (BESS) at 4664 Wetzel Rd.
●Chairwoman Michelle Berton and member Jim Palumbo recused themselves from voting on Nexamp projects due to business ties.
Community Discussion
0 commentsBe the first to comment on this story.