📐 Planning Board
Credit Union Expansion, Warehouse Subdivision Headline Busy Planning Session
The Town of Clay Planning Board moved forward with a new credit union and warehouse expansions during their October 22 meeting, while continuing to refine traffic plans for a proposed Route 31 shopping center.
▶
Key Actions & Decisions
●
Red Barn Extension Approved: The board granted final plat approval for "Red Barn Extension (3)" on Buckley Road, clearing the way for 17 single-family homes on 8.6 acres. (Vote: 5-0)
●
Credit Union Endorsed: The board recommended a special permit for Northern Credit Union to build a 3,100 sq. ft. branch with a drive-thru at 3584 State Route 31, though site plan review was extended to November 19. (Vote: 5-0)
●
Warehouse Modifications: An amended site plan for 7245 Henry Clay Blvd. to subdivide a facility into three tenant spaces was tabled until November 19 pending wetland permit documentation. (Vote: 5-0)
●
Shopping Center Traffic: Review of the Mirabito Shopping Center site plan was extended after the deputy chair raised concerns regarding traffic circulation conflicts near the proposed drive-thru.
●
Two Cases Withdrawn: The Emerald Lawn Care site plan was adjourned to November 19 at the applicant's request, and the Amerco Real Estate amended site plan was withdrawn.
**CLAY** – A proposed credit union expansion and a major warehouse subdivision took center stage as the Town of Clay Planning Board convened for a busy session on October 22, addressing developments that will shape the town’s commercial corridors.
The meeting, led by Deputy Chair Michelle Borton, saw the board grant final approval for a residential subdivision while continuing to scrutinize site plans for commercial projects along Route 31 and Henry Clay Boulevard.
**Red Barn Development Gets Green Light**
In a unanimous decision, the board approved the final plat for the "Red Barn Extension (3)" located off Buckley Road. Presented by Tim Coyer of Ianuzi & Romans, the proposal involves an 8.6-acre parcel that will be developed into 17 residential single-family homes.
The approval moves based on a map dated September 17, 2024, and is conditioned upon the applicant meeting all legal and engineering requirements set by the Town of Clay.
**New Credit Union for Route 31**
The board moved to recommend a special permit for a new Northern Credit Union branch at 3584 State Route 31 (Kimbrook Plaza). The proposal, brought forward by Jim Ballantyne of Napierala Consulting, outlines a 3,100-square-foot facility featuring a drive-thru and an internal ring road.
While the board voted 5-0 to recommend the special permit to the Town Board, the actual site plan review was extended to November 19 to allow for final refinements.
Board members utilized the delay to request specific technical clarifications. Deputy Chair Borton asked that previously granted variances—specifically for building setbacks received on August 11, 2025—be clearly noted on the plan with dates and case numbers. Additionally, the board requested that the building height to the peak be detailed on architectural drawings.
Members also expressed concern regarding the landscaping buffer along the southern property line. Board Member Jim Palumbo questioned the width of the drive aisle, currently set at 30 feet, suggesting a reduction to 24 feet to prevent damage to proposed Bradford Pear trees from vehicle traffic or snow storage.
**Warehouse Complex Subdivision**
Significant changes are in store for the warehouse facility at 7245 Henry Clay Blvd. The board reviewed an amended site plan presented by Alex Samoray of Keplinger Freeman Associates on behalf of Ironhorn Enterprises.
The proposal seeks to subdivide the existing southern facility into three separate spaces to accommodate three tenants. This expansion requires increasing the paved area, updating stormwater management facilities, and adding landscaping.
A key point of discussion was the management of on-site wetlands. Samoray noted that the project aims to keep wetland encroachment to half an acre, and jurisdictional determinations have been made by the Army Corps of Engineers.
Deputy Chair Borton emphasized that the board would need to see documentation regarding wetland permits before moving forward. The board also requested written clarification regarding a shared water service arrangement with OCWA to ensure the service line is not improperly subdivided. This case was adjourned to November 19.
**Traffic Concerns Delay Mirabito Review**
The most extensive discussion of the evening concerned the Mirabito Shopping Center proposed for 5566 State Route 31. Matt Napierala of Napierala Consulting returned with responses to comments from a previous September meeting, addressing issues ranging from neighborhood buffers to EV chargers.
However, progress stalled regarding the site's traffic circulation. The 9.57-acre site is split between commercial (HC-1) and residential (R-7.5) zones. To protect the neighboring residential area, which serves as a stormwater facility for the Lawton Valley development, the applicant proposed a landscape buffer of Norway spruces and a 6-foot stockade fence.
Despite these buffers, Deputy Chair Borton raised concerns about "too many circulation conflicts," specifically regarding the egress exit from the proposed Dunkin’ Donuts drive-thru. Borton suggested moving fuel pumps 30 feet to the west to create better separation for the drive-thru exit lane—a suggestion previously made by Chairperson Russ Mitchell.
Napierala agreed to revisit the traffic flow. The board also requested written confirmation from both the Clay and Cicero highway departments that they have no concerns regarding the project, particularly in light of Lawton Road being scheduled for repaving in 2026.
**Other Business**
Several other items were on the agenda:
* **Seneca Savings:** The site plan for a new branch at 5332 State Route 31 was adjourned to November 19 following the removal of a dumpster from the plans and the filing of an easement agreement.
* **Amerco Real Estate:** The applicant withdrew the amended site plan for 8015 Oswego Road.
* **Emerald Lawn Care:** The applicant requested an adjournment for the site plan at 4663 Wetzel Road, pushing the review to November 19.
The next regular meeting of the Clay Planning Board is scheduled for November 19, 2025.
Coverage of the Planning Board meeting on 2025-10-22,
Town of Clay, NY.
View original document ↗
This article was drafted by AI (claude-sonnet-4-20250514) from the official meeting transcript and reviewed by a human editor.
Quotes link to source video timestamps for verification.
Read our editorial policy.
🔍
Ask Clay
Have a question about this story? Search across meeting transcripts, town history, and municipal code.
Related Planning Board Meetings
2025-10-08
Planning Board Backs Rezoning for 80-90 New Homes on West Taft Road
▶
Key Actions & Decisions
●
Planning Board voted 6-0 to recommend the Town Board approve a zone change for 5300 West Taft Road from Limited Use/Restaurant and R-10 to Office (O-2) and R-7.5 districts.
●
The project proposes 80-90 single-family dwellings, a low-intensity office building, and a daycare center on 29.1 acres.
●
Public hearing opened and closed regarding the zone change; comments forwarded to the Town Board.
●
Seneca Savings site plan review adjourned to Oct. 22 following discussion on dumpster placement and septic approval.
●
Canandaigua National Bank site plan (7515 & 7519 Oswego Road) approved following public hearing.
●
Site plan reviews for John Fisher Construction, Byrne Dairy, and Emerald Lawn Care adjourned to later dates.
2025-11-19
Byrne Dairy, Seneca Savings Plans Approved; Mirabito Site Plan Faces Further Review
▶
Key Actions & Decisions
●
Approved site plan for Byrne Dairy at 7190 Buckley Road (Vote: 6-0)
●
Approved site plan for Seneca Savings at 5332 State Route 31 (Vote: 6-0)
●
Approved site plan for Emerald Lawn Care at 4663 Wetzel Road (Vote: 6-0)
●
Continued Mirabito Shopping Center review to Dec. 10, 2025 (Vote: 6-0)
●
Adjourned John E. Fisher Construction cases to Jan. 14, 2026
●
Adjourned Sharkey’s zone change referral to Feb. 11, 2026
2025-09-24
Micron Support Facility to Reduce Truck Traffic; Planning Board Reviews Site Plan
▶
Key Actions & Decisions
●
RailWorks Presentation: Board received a preliminary presentation on a 38-acre rail spur facility at 8625 Caughdenoy Road to support Micron construction via rail rather than truck.
●
Windsor Property Group: Unanimously approved the preliminary and final plat for a business park at 7985 Morgan Road (Case #2025-021, #2025-022).
●
Byrne Dairy: Continued review of site plan adjustments for 7190 Buckley Road to October 8, pending lighting plan sign-off from Onondaga County.
●
Canandaigua National Bank: Continued site plan review for 7515-7519 Oswego Road to October 8 to finalize engineering details and landscaping.
●
Northern Credit Union: Adjourned site plan and special permit review for 5004-5008 West Taft Road to October 8.
●
Chad Mutter: Adjourned EV charging station site plan for 7293 Buckley Road to November 19; no applicant present.
●
Morgan Road Business Park: Adjourned site plan review to November 19.
●
Rich Family Subdivision: Adjourned zone change referral for 8100-8101 Oasis Lane to October 8.
2025-09-10
Credit Union Proposal Advances; Board Green Lights Pack Rat Storage
▶
Key Actions & Decisions
●
Approved site plan for Pack Rat Storage at 4717 Wetzel Road (Vote: 7-0).
●
Voted to request a zoning interpretation for the Mirabito Shopping Center project due to an August ZBA deadlock.
●
Continued review of Northern Credit Union site plan to Sept. 24 to address traffic and landscaping details.
●
Adjourned Byrne Dairy and Seneca Savings reviews to future dates.
●
Accepted the resignation/recusal of Planning Board Engineer Ron DeTota (noted as absent).
●
Agreed Northern Credit Union lights should be lowered to 18 feet to protect neighbors.
2025-12-10
Medical Mall Plans Advance, Equestrian Center Moves Forward in Clay Planning Review
▶
Key Actions & Decisions
●
Great Northern Medical Complex: Board granted preliminary plat approval (7-0) for Conifer LLC to subdivide 121 acres, facilitating a partnership with SUNY Upstate Medical University.
●
National Grid Shredder: Approved a special permit (7-0) for a new metal shredder line at 4651 Crossroads Park Dr. to recycle aluminum cable.
●
Clay Equestrian Center: Public hearing adjourned to Jan. 14, 2026, to allow time for septic and wetland designs to be finalized.
●
Northside Baptist Church: Public hearing on an 18,977 sq. ft. expansion adjourned to Jan. 14, 2026, to address lighting details.
Community Discussion
0 commentsBe the first to comment on this story.