clayny.news

AI for transparency
Clay, New York · Sunday, September 20, 2026· Sep 20, 2026
🏛️ Town Board

Clay Town Board Adopts Permit-Fee Law, Advances $30 Million Micron Host Agreement for Fab 1

2026-07-07 · 2008 words
Read Article →

Key Actions & Decisions

  • Board approved Local Law No. 7 of 2026, the "Large-Scale Development Permit and Community Host Agreement Authorization Law," 6-0, letting developers of projects costing $100 million or more voluntarily enter Community Host Agreements instead of paying standard permit fees.
  • Officials said the existing fee formula ($100 for the first $1,000 of project value, $7 per $1,000 after) conflicts with a state requirement that permit fees cover only the town's service costs, and becomes unworkable at billion-dollar scale; the new law takes effect once filed with the New York Secretary of State.
  • The board held an informational hearing on a proposed Community Host Agreement with Micron New York Semiconductor Manufacturing, LLC, covering only Fab 1 of Micron's planned four-factory, $51 billion Clay campus.
  • Presentation materials describe a three-year, $30 million agreement: $20 million paid to the town over three annual installments plus $10 million in Green Chips Act funding directed exclusively to Clay.
  • The minutes give two different figures for Fab 1's cost and associated fee — $89 billion/$69 million during the public hearing discussion versus $8.9 billion/$62 million in the presentation slides — a discrepancy the minutes do not resolve.
  • Resident Shelly Hotaling cited different figures still — $15 million for fees/inspections and $6 million for the town — and asked that the agreement go to a public vote; Deputy Supervisor Bick said it would not go to referendum but resident input would factor into the process.
  • Residents raised concerns about construction trucks on Morgan Road, noise and water mitigation tied to state DEC requirements, and requested infrastructure spending on public sewers, low-cost housing, and Meltzer Park restrooms; one resident proposed a citizens advisory board.
  • Deputy Supervisor Bick moved a resolution approving the Community Host Agreement with Micron, seconded by Councilor David Capria; the minutes do not record a specific vote tally for that motion before adjournment.
  • The meeting, chaired by Deputy Supervisor Joseph Bick in the absence of Supervisor Damian Ulatowski, adjourned 6-0 at 6:17 P.M.

The Clay Town Board voted 6-0 to adopt a law letting large developers enter voluntary 'Community Host Agreements' in place of standard building permit fees, then held an informational hearing on a proposed three-year, $30 million host agreement with Micron covering the first of its four planned chip fabrication buildings in Clay.

Topics
Micron & White Pine Commerce Park
People
Joseph Bick (Deputy Supervisor / Town Councilor) Russ Mitchell (Planning Board Chairman (predecessor to Borton)) Damian Ulatowski (Town Supervisor) Hal Henty (Planning Board Member) Eugene Young (Town Councilor) Michelle Borton (Commissioner of Planning & Development; Planning Board Chair) Ron DeTota (Town Attorney) Jill Hageman-Clark (Town Councilor (2026- ); previously Town Clerk) Robert Germain (Town Clerk) Edward Wisnowski (Town Councilor) David Capria (Town Councilor) Marie Giannone (Planning Board Secretary) Brian Bender (Town Engineer; also served as Commissioner of Planning & Development) Ryan Russell (Town Councilor (2026- )) Courtney Gauthier (Town Councilor (2026- ))

Typeset from the official record — motions and recorded votes are detected automatically. The official copy governs.

APPROVED

At the SPECIAL MEETING of the Town Board, Town of Clay, Onondaga County, held at the Town Hall, Clay, New York on July 7th, 2026, at 5:30 P.M., there were:

PRESENT:

Joseph Bick Deputy Supervisor/Councilor Eugene Young Councilor David Capria - Councilor Edward Wisnowski ‘Councilor Ryan Russell Councilor Courtney Gauthier - Councilor Jill Hageman-Clark Town Clerk Robert Germain Town Attorney Ron DeTota Town Engineer Brian Bender Commissioner Planning & Development

ABSENT:

Damian Ulatowski Supervisor OTHERS PRESENT:

Michelle Borton, Planning Board Chair; Russ Mitchell, Hal Henty and Paul Graves, Planning Board Members; Marie Giannone, Planning Board Secretary and Rob Bick, Town Assessor.

The meeting was called to order by Deputy Supervisor Bick at 5:30 P.M. All present joined in the Pledge of Allegiance.

APPROVAL of MINUTES:

Councilor Young made a motion to approve the minutes of June 29t» 2026 Special

Town Board Meeting. Motion was seconded by Councilor Capria.

Ayes — 6 and Noes — 0. Motion carried.

REGULAR MEETING

LOCAL LAW No. 7 OF THE YEAR 2026 — Adjusting Building Permit Fees for Large Scale Projects and permit Community Host Agreements:

A public hearing to consider proposed LOCAL LAW NO. 7 OF THE YEAR 2026 to be known as “Large-Scale Development Permit and Community Host Agreement Authorization Law.” Proposed local law would authorize adjustments to building permit fees for large-scale projects and permit Community Host Agreements was opened by the Deputy Supervisor.

REGULAR MEETING OF THE TOWN BOARD - July 7, 2026 Town of Clay

Deputy Supervisor Bick explained that the way the Code reads now is prohibitive to large scale development. Local Law number 7 of the Year 2026 will allow developers to construct with approval and allow funding for this such as improvements to

infrastructure and community projects. As the Code reads now all money collected can be used only for inspection costs.

Law defines Large scale development as costing $100,000,000.00 and greater. Currently the fee based on the cost at $100.00 for the first $1,000.00 and $7.00 per thousand after. This Local Law for a Voluntary Host Agreement will be a compromise

allowing a break for Large Scale development as well as improving the quality of life for the residents of the Town.

Deputy Supervisor explained that if this Local Law is passed it will go into effect when filed with the State.

Shelly Hotalling asked if the money from the Host Agreement can be used to hire outside inspectors and industrial experts. Deputy Supervisor Bick said that it could.

Another resident asked what would happen if a developer did not wish to participate in the Host Agreement. Deputy Supervisor Bick reiterated, it is completely voluntary. He continued, there is'no model for fees of this magnitude. The cost for Fab 1 is $89 billion and the Permit fees would be $69 million. The money could only be used for inspections under the current law.

There being no more questions or comments, he closed the public hearing.

Informational Hearing (PH) - Micron New York Semiconductor Manufacturing, LLC:

Informational hearing for proposed Community Host Agreement between the Town of Clay and Micron New York Semiconductor Manufacturing, LLC was opened by the Deputy Supervisor, who presented a PowerPoint presentation about the agreement (attached). H

Questions and answers followed.

Councilor Young asked, under the current law fees could only be used for inspections - correct.

Councilor Russell added that the money that would be collected exceeds the Town Budget, this is very impactful.

Paul Doody asked what the breakdown is of the $30 million; $20 million over three years and $10 million dedicated in Green Chips spending exclusively for the Town. Alan Mokay asked if Micron offered this. Deputy Supervisor Bick said it was negotiated and discussed between Micron and the Town of Clay.

REGULAR MEETING OF THE TOWN BOARD - July 7, 2026 Town of Clay

Someone asked if the Law can be changed. The Local Law makes it possible for

future (Large Scale) development to voluntarily opt in to a Community Host Agreement with the Town of Clay.

Councilor Russell reminded, this is only for the Fab 1 part of this development.

Deputy Supervisor Bick said this is a pioneer agreement, nothing like this currently exists. He added that they have done due diligence to ensure everyone benefits.

Councilor Young said that there will be money to spend, and residents will have the opportunity to have their voices heard. Sewers, Roads, Parks, Splash Pads....

Shelly Hotaling asked how much Micron offered? $15 million for fees/inspections and $6 million for the Town. She added, this should go up for public vote. Deputy

Supervisor Bick said this would‘not go to a referendum, but the residents’ input will

be part of the process. ,

Evan Nobis asked how they decided on $30 million, what if there is not much leftover. What about sound barriers and mitigation of water from DEC. He wants to make sure the public opinion is considered.

Paul Doody asked about a citizen’s advisory board/council. Chuck from Fairways said the trucks on Morgan Road are a concern. Morgan Road was not designed for them. Deputy Supervisor Bick said that the construction vehicles are not supposed to be using Morgan Road. He said to call the Town Hall with trucking company names if seen on Morgan Road. The rail spur once completed will alleviate some of the construction traffic.

Aaron Schanbacher asked if this money will be used for expanding the infrastructure? He suggested low-cost housing, restrooms at the Meltzer Park

playground and public sewers for residents currently without.

There being no more questions or comments, Deputy Supervisor Bick closed the informational hearing.

ADDITIONAL AGENDA

LOCAL LAW No. 7 OF THE YEAR 2026 (A) Adjusting Building Permit Fees for Large Scale Projects and permit Community Host Agreements:

Deputy Supervisor Bick moved the adoption of a resolution, that:

REGULAR MEETING OF THE TOWN BOARD - July 7, 2026 Town of Clay Page 4 of 4 7

Whereas, the Town of Clay proposed LOCAL LAW No. 7 of the YEAR 2026 to be

known as LARGE-SCALE DEVELOPMENT PERMIT and COMMUNITY HOST AGREMENT AUTHORIZATION LAW, and

Whereas, the Town of Clay held a public hearing on July 7, 2026 and duly

considered the need and application of the proposed new Local Law as presented, and recognizes adoption is a necessary step to allow authorized adjustments to building permit fees for large-scale projects and to further permit the Town to enter into Community Host Agreements when appropriate, it is hereby:

RESOLVED

The new Local Law No. 7 of the Year 2026 is a Type II Action for the purpose of SEQRA compliance with no other permit granting authority outside the Town. Accordingly, no further action SEQRA evaluation is required. This Board hereby Approves the new Local Law No. 7 of the Year 2026 as presented. The new law will become effective upon filing with the New York State Secretary of State. Motion was seconded by Councilor Capria.

Ayes — 6 and Noes — 0. Motion carried.

COMMUNITY HOST AGREEMENT (A):

Deputy Supervisor Bick moved the adoption of a resolution approving the

Community Host Agreement between the Town of Clay and Micron New York

Semiconductor Manufacturing, LLC. Motion was seconded by Councilor Capria

Adjournment:

The meeting was adjourned at 6:17 P.M. upon motion by Councilor Young and seconded by Councilor Capria.

Ayes — 6 and Noes — 0. Motion carried.

Que aed —

Hageman JC lark RMC / Town Clerk

Community Host Agreement Between Micron and the Town of Clay

\ great place to live, work, and raise a family. TOW Ne ‘Cc LAY

Starting points

¢ Mieron will build four (4) Chip Fabrication factories in Clay valued at 51 Billion dollars.

* The Town of Clay must issue building permits associated with this construction over the next 15-20 Years.

* Town law requires a building permit fee based on the valueof the project being built. ($100 for the 1S $1000 in value; $7.00 for every $1000 after that).

* State law requires building permit fees to only cover the cost of services provided.

TOWN: CLAY

A great place to live, work, and raise a family,

The Challenge

* There is no model for fees associated with private development of this magnitude (Largest semiconductor manufacturing facility in US History)

* The town's formula is very accurate and appropriate for usual development of a traditional size, but it becomes excessive when applied to billion-dollar projects.

* Town Law and State Law are at odds for a project this size.

S

A great place to live, work, and raise a family. TOWN CLAY

The Risks

* Micron would have to pay the full amount prior to the issuance of permits and the beginning of construction.

» Micron has timelines and deliverables to New York State and the Federal government and OCIDA to meet to retain the incentives they have been offered.

* The town would get sued to recover the fees and a judge would decide how much it would cost the town to provide the service (the town could end up with less than.1 million dollars if a judge decides) case law supports this.

* The town would incur further cost to taxpayers defending a suit. Bad blood between the town, its residents, and Micron.

A great place to live, work, and raise a family. TOWN CLAY

The Negotiation

* Initial conversation was for a fee based on the 51-billion-dollar value of the entire 4 chip fab project (~273 Million) as required by town law.

* Subsequent conversations challenged the valuation of the project and the length of the.agreement, as well as the town’s cost for providing the service.

* Initial ask from the town was 150 million over 15 years for the entire project (Would cover the towns cost and compensate residents for the inconvenience of development for the duration of the project)

* Without an agreement no permits would be issued unless the full permit fee was paid.

er A great place to live, work, and raise a family, TOWM > CLAY

The Compromise

* The Agreement will enly cover the construction of Chip Fab 1 witha construction cost of 8.9 Billion dollars. (62 Million Dollar Fee under the current town code) * The agreement will last three (3) years at a cost to Micron of 30 Million dollars + Expenses incurred prior to the agreement would not be included.

* Town law would be changed to allow for community host agreements.and fee adjustments/waivers.

* 20 Million over 3 years in three annual payments and another 10 million in dedicated Green Chips Act spending exclusively in the Town of Clay over the same period.

A great place to live, work, and raise a family. TOWN.» CLAY

Key points around the agreement

* Its Limits: Issues negotiated and agreed to by OCIDA, NYS and the Federal Government (Environmental impact Statement, roads, land, environmental offsets etc.) are not part of this agreement.

+ The standards of work: The standards for building permits are not changed or waived. The agreement is only for cost.

* How the majority is spent: So long as the Town of Clay's cost of administering requirements around permits is covered, all other money will be-used at the town's discretion.

A great place to live, work, and raise a family. TOWMN-+ CLAY

Accountability and Uses

* Fiscal controls for town spending remain in place * Continued Independent audits of town finances * Budget and spending subject to town board approval and public hearings * Public disclosure of all financial records as require by law * Annual ethics disclosures by public officials

* Monies to be used to offset taxpayer expense over time and enhance the livability of the town for its residents * Town retains control over issuance of permits and has the legal authority to order work stoppages. -

i] “ea A great place tolive, work, and raise a family. TOWN = CLAY

THANK YOU!

Questions and Comments

i

A great place to live, work, and raise a family. TOWN CLAY